Tuesday, October 16, 2007

Topic Proposal

As you approach the hostess’ stand, she asks you a simple, but important question: Smoking or Non-Smoking. You can either wait for an hour to get a table in the non smoking section, or you can be seated immediately in the cloud of tobacco smoke that hangs over the smoking section. Should smoking be outlawed in restaurants and other public places to satisfy nonsmoking clients, or should the laws be left the way they have been for years?

My paper will argue that smoking bans should be put into effect in all public places. These bans aren’t meant to single out smokers and make them uncomfortable. The smoking bans should be put into place to protect those who don’t smoke, but are inevitably affected. Having a nonsmoking section of a restaurant is like having a no peeing section of a pool. One way or another, everything mixes. I will also discuss the opposing view as well as the history of tobacco
use and the outcome of smoking bans that have already been put into effect.

My audience will be my classmates, my teacher, and anyone else who is interested in the smoking ban topic. I hope that my paper will be informative while being interesting as well.



Huang, P, MD. "Impact of a Smoking Ban on Restaurant and Bar Revenues." Center for Disease Control.
26 Feb. 2004. 15 Oct. 2007 .

Lung USA. June 2007. American Lung Association. 15 Oct. 2007 .

"Smoking and Your Body." Healthy Living. 6 Oct. 2005. Health Canada. 15 Oct.
2007 .

"Smoking Ban." Wikipedia. 15 Oct. 2007. 15 Oct. 2007 .

"Tobacco Industry's Targeting of Youth, Minorities and Women." American Heart. 2007. American Heart Association. 15 Oct. 2007 .

2 comments:

Anna Mkhaylova said...

Ally, you seem to have a very strong stance on the issue and I even appreciate the analogy you included in your claim :-) However, your claim and, if developed according to your plan, the paper will meet the requirements of Essay #4: the policy/proposal paper. The main purpose of Essay #3 it to explore multiple perspectives on an issue, not to argue extensively on one. So, ideally, you will use revised version this topic proposal for Essay# 4. In this paper, paper, however, you can focus on who benefits/loses from having smoking sections at restaurants or you can explore the history/motivation/outcomes of smoking bans to date. In any case, reserve your policy decision for Essay#4:-)

Tyler Bennett said...

As a self-proclaimed artisan of analogies, I commend the statement:

"Having a nonsmoking section of a restaurant is like having a no peeing section of a pool."

Brilliant, perfectly accurate, and hilarious.